Luke Grimes Says ‘Yellowstone’ Spinoff ‘Marshals’ Could Continue for Years: “I Love Playing Kayce”
After a huge first-season response, Luke Grimes is embracing Kayce Dutton’s next chapter while remaining cautious about how long the CBS series will run.
Luke Grimes is feeling much more confident about the future of Marshals after initially having serious doubts about bringing Kayce Dutton back to television.
The actor, who stars as Kayce and executive produces the Yellowstone spinoff, says the response to the CBS series has changed his expectations. While he originally believed the show might last only one season, its strong debut has made the possibility of a much longer run feel increasingly realistic.
“I love playing Kayce,” Grimes told The Hollywood Reporter. “This has been the greatest character of my life, and here I am, nine years later, still playing him.”
That enthusiasm comes as Marshals enters its second season with a 20-episode order and a larger role for Kayce as he balances his work as a U.S. marshal with life at East Camp.
Grimes initially wasn’t sure Kayce needed another chapter
Grimes had already made peace with Kayce’s Yellowstone ending before Marshals came along.
The character had left the flagship series alongside Monica Dutton and their son, Tate, appearing to have finally found a quieter future away from the Dutton family’s long-running conflicts. For Grimes, that ending felt satisfying enough that he wasn’t immediately convinced another series was necessary.
“I was so prepared to let Kayce go, and then once I had let it go, I missed it,” he said.
That hesitation continued even after he agreed to return. Marshals represented a significant change in format, moving Kayce from the sprawling Yellowstone family drama into a CBS series built partly around U.S. Marshal cases.
The gamble paid off.
According to Grimes, the response was stronger than anyone involved expected, particularly on streaming. That reception gave him confidence that audiences were willing to follow Kayce into a very different world.
Monica’s death remains central to Kayce’s story
One of the biggest changes between Yellowstone and Marshals was revealed almost immediately.
The spinoff established that Monica had died from cancer linked to toxic contamination on the Broken Rock Reservation sometime between the two shows. Her death became the emotional foundation for Kayce’s new story.
Grimes admits that the decision was difficult for him personally because Kayce’s original journey was so closely tied to Monica.
“My whole arc [on Yellowstone] was about our family,” he said.
That loss continues to shape the character in season two. Grimes pointed to one particularly revealing detail: Kayce is still wearing his wedding ring deep into filming.
For Kayce, moving forward doesn’t mean forgetting Monica.
Grimes described their relationship as essentially a “Romeo & Juliet” story — two people caught between opposing families who nevertheless couldn’t stop loving each other. Anyone who eventually enters Kayce’s life will therefore have to understand that Monica will remain an important part of who he is.
Kayce’s next romance has already taken a dark turn
Season one introduced Dolly Weaver as a possible romantic interest for Kayce, but the season two premiere quickly ended that possibility.
Dolly was killed during a standoff involving her father, Tom Weaver, who has emerged as a major threat to Kayce after betraying him and taking Tate.
Grimes says he was initially uncomfortable with the idea of Kayce becoming romantically involved with someone else so soon after Monica’s death.
“I was sort of dreading it, honestly,” he admitted.
But he now believes the timing makes more sense. Kayce is becoming increasingly isolated, while Tate is getting older and preparing to leave his father’s immediate orbit.
Grimes sees that loneliness as an important part of Kayce’s future. The character will need people around him, both romantically and through the community he is building with his fellow marshals.
‘Marshals’ is still part procedural, part Dutton drama
One of the show’s defining characteristics is its unusual format.
Grimes doesn’t consider Marshals a traditional procedural in which viewers can watch episodes independently without knowing the larger story. At the same time, it isn’t simply another serialized Dutton family drama.
Instead, the series combines the two approaches.
There are individual cases and new adversaries for Kayce and his fellow marshals, but larger storylines continue throughout the season. That gives the show the flexibility of a procedural while maintaining an ongoing narrative.
Season two is also expanding the ensemble around Kayce. Grimes says his relationships with Cal and Belle, played by Logan Marshall-Green and Arielle Kebbel, become deeper as the team gradually begins to function like a new family for him.
That development is especially important because Kayce is losing the family life that once defined him.
Jimmy’s return makes ‘Marshals’ feel like ‘Yellowstone’ again
One of the most recognizable Yellowstone connections coming to Marshals is Jefferson White’s Jimmy Hurdstrom.
Grimes says the idea emerged naturally during conversations with showrunner Spencer Hudnut about how to expand Kayce’s world.
After learning that the planned Jimmy-centered 6666 spinoff was no longer moving forward, Grimes suggested contacting White. White was enthusiastic, and the idea quickly received approval.
Jimmy arrives at East Camp to help Kayce with the ranch and other responsibilities.
For Grimes, bringing the character back has been more than simple fan service.
“It really feels like we’re shooting Yellowstone again,” he said.
Jimmy’s return also gives Marshals another way to connect with the original series without turning the new show into a continuation of Yellowstone.
A Beth and Kayce crossover isn’t happening yet
Fans hoping to see Kayce reunite with Beth Dutton may have to wait.
Grimes says he doesn’t expect a crossover with Kelly Reilly’s Beth anytime soon, arguing that both shows need time to establish themselves independently.
Still, he believes a meeting eventually makes sense.
Beth is Kayce’s only living sibling, apart from his son Tate, and the actor doesn’t think anyone involved is opposed to the idea.
For now, however, Marshals is focused on building its own identity.
That separation is also why Grimes hasn’t watched Dutton Ranch, the spinoff centered on Beth and Rip. He said the two series have deliberately taken different approaches, with Dutton Ranch functioning more as a continuation of Yellowstone, while Marshals has had to adapt Kayce’s world to a network procedural format.
Grimes isn’t planning too far ahead
Despite the show’s success, Grimes isn’t claiming that Marshals is guaranteed to run for several more seasons.
He says he and Hudnut are approaching the series one season at a time.
There is no firm number of seasons currently mapped out, and Grimes believes thinking too far ahead could potentially hurt the storytelling. For now, his focus is simply on making season two work.
That doesn’t mean he isn’t open to staying with Kayce for years.
After nearly a decade with the character, Grimes says he has learned not to make assumptions about how long any television role will last.
“That’s so out of my hands,” he said. “All I can really do is be in the moment and do the work that’s in front of me right now.”
For the moment, that work is season two. Grimes revealed that production had already completed episode 13 and was moving into episode 14 when the interview took place.
And while the actor remains careful about predicting the future, his feelings about Kayce are clear: he isn’t eager to say goodbye again.
Marshals airs Sundays from 8–9 p.m. on CBS, with episodes available to stream on Paramount+.
