Disney’s $250 Million Gamble? Live-Action ‘Moana’ Opens No. 1 but Falls Short of Expectations
Disney may have claimed the top spot at the box office this weekend, but its highly anticipated live-action “Moana” didn’t exactly make the waves many expected.
Despite debuting as the No. 1 movie in North America, the film earned $43 million domestically and $52 million overseas, bringing its global opening weekend total to $95 million. For most movies, that’s a respectable start—but for a production carrying a reported $250 million budget, the numbers have left industry analysts asking whether Disney’s latest remake can recover its enormous investment.
Disney entered the weekend with sky-high expectations.
The original 2016 animated “Moana“ became one of the company’s biggest streaming successes, ranking as the most-watched movie on Disney+. Its sequel, “Moana 2,” shattered Thanksgiving records in 2024 and eventually sailed past the $1 billion mark worldwide.
That success made the live-action adaptation seem like a safe bet.
Instead, the remake has delivered one of Disney’s softer openings for a major live-action reboot.
Critics Didn’t Hold Back
While newcomer Catherine Lagaʻaia earned praise for her portrayal of Moana and Dwayne Johnson returned as the beloved demigod Maui, critics weren’t impressed with the film itself.
Many reviews described it as a near shot-for-shot remake of the original animated classic, questioning whether the new version offered anything fresh.
The movie currently holds just 34% on Rotten Tomatoes, making it one of Disney’s lower-rated live-action remakes.
Audiences Are More Positive
Moviegoers, however, appear more forgiving than critics.
According to audience surveys:
63% said they would definitely recommend the movie.
78% of parents said they’d recommend it to other families.
The film also earned a respectable A- CinemaScore, suggesting strong word-of-mouth among younger audiences.
That could help the movie stay afloat in the coming weeks even if its opening wasn’t spectacular.
Too Many Family Movies at Once?
Industry analysts believe timing may have worked against Disney.
Family audiences currently have several major choices in theaters, including:
Minions & Monsters – $20.5 million
Toy Story 5 – $18.5 million
Moana – $43 million
With three big PG-rated films competing for the same audience, many families simply had to choose one.
Even after four weekends, Toy Story 5 continues to perform strongly, pushing its worldwide total to nearly $880 million.
Horror Brings Different Competition
Outside the family market, Warner Bros.’ new horror release “Evil Dead Burn” opened with $13.7 million, below previous films in the franchise.
Meanwhile, Angel Studios’ “Young Washington” remained in the top five, while Olivia Wilde’s “The Invite” made a modest debut.
Another Billion-Dollar Winner Emerges
While newer releases fought for attention, one movie quietly reached an impressive milestone.
“Michael,” the Michael Jackson biopic, officially crossed $1 billion worldwide, becoming only the second film this year to achieve that feat. It has also overtaken “Bohemian Rhapsody” as the highest-grossing musical biopic ever released.
Top 10 Domestic Box Office This Weekend
Rank
Movie
Weekend Gross
1
Moana
$43 million
2
Minions & Monsters
$20.5 million
3
Toy Story 5
$18.5 million
4
Evil Dead Burn
$13.7 million
5
Young Washington
$6.4 million
6
The Invite
$5.7 million
7
Obsession
$3.8 million
8
Supergirl
$3.6 million
9
Disclosure Day
$3.2 million
10
Backrooms
$1.5 million
Can ‘Moana’ Turn Things Around?
Opening weekend isn’t always the final verdict. Disney has seen films recover after slow starts, especially family titles that benefit from school holidays and strong word-of-mouth.
Still, with a $250 million production budget—before marketing costs—“Moana” will need exceptional staying power at the global box office to prove Disney’s live-action strategy still has plenty of life left.